Honors
All-Americans
1968: John Smith (130, 4th)
1979: Randy Waggoner (190, 5th)
1980: Scott Lowery (158, 6th)
1982: John Howard (167, 8th), Jim Kattelmann (126, 6th)
1993: Jim Prendergast (158, 6th)
MIAA Champions
1970: Bryan O'Brien (167), Mike Aston (190)
1971: Ragon Steele (142)
1972: Ragon Steele (142), Tom Coil (177)
1973: Tom Coil (177)
1974: John Williamson (134)
1977: Scott Lowery (158)
1978: Mike Oldham (150)
1979: Bob Hritz (134), Randy Waggoner (190)
1980: Bob Hritz (134)
1981: Jim Kattelman (126), Scott Lowery (158), Dennis Whitehouse (167), Terry Jasper (Heavyweight)
All-MIAA
1968: Allan Chase (123), Ardie McCoy (167)
1969: Levi McCoy (152), Ardie McCoy (167)
1970: Bryan O'Brien (167), Mike Aston (190)
1971: Ragon Steele (142)
1972: Ragon Steele (142), Tom Coil (177)
1973: Tom Coil (177)
1974: John Williamson (134)
1977: Scott Lowery (158)
1978: Mike Oldham (150)
1979: Randy Waggoner (190)
1980: Bob Hritz (134)
1981: Jim Kattelmann (126), Scott Lowery (158), Dennis Whitehouse (167), Terry Jasper (Heavyweight)
MIAA Outstanding Wrestler
1971: Ragon Steele (142)
1972: Tom Coil (177)
MIAA Coach of the Year
1980: Mike McCarty
1981: Mike McCarty
Division I NCAA Qualifiers (Weight class in regional placing)
1984: Norm Dahm (158, 4th)
1987: Jon Frangoulis (190, 2nd)
1988: Jon Frangoulis (190, 1st), Joe Williams (126, 2nd)
1989: Jeff Harris (167, 1st)
1990: Jerry Hickey (134, 1st)
1991: Ted Hickey (150, 2nd)
1992: John Krause (142, 3rd)
1993: Ted Hickey (150, 2nd), Tony Dong (126, 2nd), David Ross (134, 2nd), Jim Prendergast (158, 3rd)
1994: Ted Hickey (150, 1st), Jim Prendergast (158, 2nd), Matt Orton (167, 3rd), David Ross (134, 2nd), John Krause (142, 2nd)
Most Valuable Wrestler
1966: Steve Stephenson
1967: John Wilhelm
1968: John Smith
1969: Ardie McCoy
1970: Bryan O'Brien
1971: Ragon Steele
1972: Tom Coil
1973: Tom Coil
1974: John Williamson
1975: Wayne Kaiser
1976: Rick Gonzales
1977: Scott Lowery
1978: Scott Lowery
1979: Mike Oldham
1980: Scott Lowery
1981: Dennis Whitehouse
1982: John Howard
1983: John Howard
1984: Norm Dahm
1985: Jim Fox
1986: John Shumate
1987: Larry Juern
1988: Jon Frangoulis
1989: Jeff Harris
1990: Jerry Hickey
1991: Ted Hickey
1992: John Krause
1993: Jim Prendergast
1994: Ted Hickey
Top Freshman
1966: John Wilhelm
1967: Bryan O'Brien
1968: Allan Chase
1969: Levi McCoy
1970: Doug Smith
1971: Joe Lemmons
1972: Wayne Kaiser
1973: Randy Diffee
1974: Ken Hill
1975: Ronnie Coffman
1976: Mike Garcia
1977: Mike Oldham
1978: Randy Waggoner
1979: Jim Kattelmann
1980: Steve Basinger
1981: Craig Wade
1982: John Shumate
1983: Jim Fox
1984: Jon Frangoulis
1985: Anthony Wright
1986: David Tindle
1987: Doug Smith
1988: James Turnage
1989: Jerry Hickey
1990: Tony Dong
1991: Jim Prendergast
1992: Matt Orton#
1993: Matt Orton#
1994: Kalin Sharkey
#No Top Freshman Award. Orton was awarded the Hardest Worker award.
Wrestling Honorees in Missouri State Athletics Hall of Fame
1989: Tom Coil
1994: Scott Lowery
1997: Ardie McCoy
2007: Jim Prendergast
